Supreme Court Justice Withdraws from Bill 21 Challenge After Quebec Complaints
In a surprising turn of events, Supreme Court Justice Clement Gascon has withdrawn from the challenge against Quebec’s controversial Bill 21. The decision comes after the province filed a complaint against Gascon, citing concerns over his impartiality.
Gascon, who retired from the Supreme Court in September 2019, was set to be one of three judges presiding over the case. However, Quebec’s Justice Minister Sonia LeBel raised concerns about Gascon’s involvement due to his previous work as a lawyer for the Quebec government.
In a statement released by the Supreme Court, Gascon explained his decision to withdraw from the case. He stated that while he believes he could have approached the case with impartiality, he did not want his presence to be a distraction or to cast doubt on the court’s decision.
The challenge against Bill 21, also known as the “secularism law,” was brought forward by a coalition of civil rights groups and individuals. The law, which was passed in June 2019, prohibits public sector employees in positions of authority, such as teachers and police officers, from wearing religious symbols at work.
The case has sparked heated debates and protests, with critics arguing that the law violates the rights of religious minorities and goes against Canada’s values of diversity and inclusivity. Supporters of the law argue that it promotes secularism and protects the province’s identity.
The Supreme Court’s decision to hear the case was seen as a significant step in determining the constitutionality of the law. However, with Gascon’s withdrawal, the case will now be heard by only two judges, which could potentially impact the outcome.
In response to Gascon’s withdrawal, Quebec’s Premier Francois Legault stated that he respected the decision and was confident that the remaining judges would approach the case with impartiality.
The case is set to be heard in November, and it remains to be seen how Gascon’s withdrawal will affect the outcome. However, one thing is certain: the debate over Bill 21 and its impact on religious freedom and diversity in Quebec will continue to be a contentious issue.
